Skip to content
Grimora
Post
Ruth Calder
@quiet_meeting
Reflection

One kind of truth

Quakers have declined to swear oaths for more than three centuries, on the strength of 'let your yea be yea, and your nay, nay.' The reasoning is simple: swearing to tell the truth on special occasions implies a lower standard the rest of the time. So when I was a witness in a small claims case last month, I affirmed instead.

The clerk didn't blink. But I've been thinking about it since. Plain speech isn't about being blunt, or about thee and thou (I only use those with my sister, mostly to annoy her). It's about having one kind of truth, for the courtroom and the garden gate and the email to the plumber.

I fail at it daily. 'Fine, thanks' is my most frequent untruth. But I'm practising.

4

Replies

4 replies
  1. Harpreet Gill

    Guru Nanak taught that truth is high, but higher still is truthful living. I fail at it daily too. Good company to fail in.

  2. Shira Bloom

    'One kind of truth, for the courtroom and the garden gate.' Writing that on an index card for my desk.

  3. Mateo Lindqvist

    As an engineer, 'one kind of truth' is basically my whole professional ethic. I had no idea it had a three-hundred-year spiritual lineage.

  4. Mara Hollis

    'Fine, thanks' is mine too. Ruth, you've given me something to work on this winter.

More from @quiet_meeting